How Our Efforts to Help LGBTQ Iranians Got A DOJ Attorney Smacked Down In Court

Published: November 19, 2026

Author: Rebekah Wolf

Topics: Asylum
How Our Efforts to Help LGBTQ Iranians Got A DOJ Attorney Smacked Down In Court The American Immigration Council is a non-profit, non-partisan organization. Sign up to receive our latest analysis as soon as it's published.

Last month, federal judge Diane Humetawa formally sanctioned a Department of Justice attorney for making unsupported declarations in written court documents. He was ordered to an hour of classes on “the special role of U.S. attorneys” and another hour on the need for “evidentiary support” for things you say in court.

This might not seem like a huge deal. But it’s very rare for judges to formally call out government attorneys for not doing the most basic part of their jobs: making sure something is true before asserting it.

It’s also ironic, because the statement he made that turned out to be untrue was accusing me of lying to ICE about my client Abed’s case.

Abed is one of the LGBTQ Iranian clients that I, the director of the Immigration Justice Campaign, have been representing for the past year. During that time, IJC has had to fight to keep Abed and his partner Ali off several flights bound for Iran — even after the U.S. went to war there this spring.

Representing Abed and Ali (as well as Ali’s spouse Zain, a trans man, who married Ali in Iran so they could present as a straight couple to avoid persecution) has been a kind of whirlwind tour in just how many ways the Trump administration has rigged immigration courts against immigrants — and how vigilant lawyers need to be in order to keep their clients safe, much less seek justice for them. The fact that this attorney accused me of obstructing official business, based on a lie, and was himself sanctioned for making assertions without having any facts to back them up instead, is a small victory. But it’s just one of several times we’ve found the government to be dishonest in trying to send Abed and Ali back to Iran.

Some quick background: Abed and Ali were arrested by the “morality police” in Iran and charged with sodomy. Zain had to put up the house he owned with Ali as collateral for the loan he took out to pay their bond. (All three of these names are pseudonyms.) The three of them fled to Turkey, but were outed there, too. On their way to the United States, they were kidnapped and assaulted in Mexico; Ali still has medical issues stemming from the attack. They fled to the U.S. for safety in early January 2025 — days before Trump took office for the second time.

IJC was connected with Zain that summer, in preparation for his case before an immigration judge. He told us that there were two witnesses who could corroborate his case — but that both had already been ordered deported.

When we looked into Abed and Ali’s case files, we discovered that neither of them had really had a fair chance to present their asylum claims. Both had told the court that they had witnesses — which, legally, means the government needed to make those witnesses available from detention to testify. But ICE didn’t do that, and the judges in each case didn’t order it.

The judge in Ali’s case expressed skepticism during the hearing that Ali — who had been charged with sodomy by the Iranian government – had actually been persecuted based on his sexual orientation. He asked, rhetorically, whether “everyone” gay in Iran is hanged.

Both Ali and Abed were ordered deported to Iran after their hearings. Furthermore, Abed’s removal order was unknowingly edited after the fact to designate his asylum claim as “frivolous,” severely limiting his options for appeal.

By the time IJC took on their cases, both men had missed their deadlines to appeal the denials of asylum. That’s because they’d been told they were unlikely to win, and decided to wait six months instead to file petitions for habeas corpus in federal court, asking federal judges to order them released from detention. They figured they could wait the six months because the U.S. wasn’t deporting anyone to Iran, and hadn’t for years.

The problem is that last summer, the U.S. made a deal with Iran to start accepting deportees.

We successfully kept Abed and Ali off the first two deportation flights. But in early December, both Abed and Ali were told they would be on the third one. We had already filed an appeal of Abed’s asylum denial with the Board of Immigration Appeals, but filed a new one on December 2, along with a request for them to officially pause — or “stay” — his deportation while his appeal was pending. Once we filed the appeal, I emailed ICE to notify them that he had a pending appeal. When ICE loaded detainees onto the plane, Abed wasn’t among them. Neither was Ali — his health had deteriorated to the point of needing a wheelchair, and he was physically incapable of sitting on the bus to the airport.

In February of this year, with the assistance of the National Immigrant Justice Center, Abed filed his habeas petition before Judge Humetawa. In its response, the government argued that Abed couldn’t claim he’d been detained for six months or longer after getting ordered deported (a benchmark that the Supreme Court found back in 2001 suggests that the person is unlikely to be deported anytime soon), because the clock had been reset each time he had “obstructed” ICE’s efforts to deport him. One of the examples of “obstruction” they used was that in December, ICE had left him off the manifest after getting a communication from his attorney — me.

The DOJ’s filing said that it was “unknowable” what I had told ICE in December, but because they took him off the deportation flight, it seemed “likely” I had told ICE that Abed had been granted a stay – which “would have been untrue.”

It would have been, had I said that! But it wasn’t. In response, Abed’s legal team produced the email I’d sent ICE at the time, which simply said, “There is now an appeal pending.”

Judge Humetawa was not impressed with the DOJ attorney’s behavior and ordered Abed released.

Meanwhile, we were still fighting for Ali’s release from detention. In May, he was told that even though he’d been granted a stay of removal from the BIA, something that almost never happens, he was going to be deported to Iran after all. (Yes, this is after military action began.) When he got moved to a facility in Arizona in preparation for a removal flight, we sprung into action again on another habeas motion. This time, we got the DOJ to agree that it was unlikely Ali would actually be removed to Iran anytime soon.

Ali was then released from detention, finally reuniting with Abed and Zain.

The way I’ve told this story doesn’t do justice to Abed, Ali, and Zain’s strength in standing up for themselves and each other. And it’s by no means the only horror story we have from the last two years of how difficult it is for asylum seekers to get a fair day in court: just ask me about the client who got ordered deported because the government handed him the wrong form. But it’s rare that we handle a case not only where our clients all end up together and free, but where the government is actually held to account for the stunts it pulls to deny people’s claims and put them on removal flights. This remarkable story is worth sharing with the world.


Bekah Wolf is the director of the Immigration Justice Campaign at the American Immigration Council. She represents Zain, Ali, and Adel. To volunteer as a pro bono attorney with IJC, please visit: Immigrationjustice.us

Related Resources

Map The Impact

Explore immigration data where you live

Our Map the Impact tool has comprehensive coverage of more than 100 data points about immigrants and their contributions in all 50 states and the country overall. It continues to be widely cited in places ranging from Gov. Newsom’s declaration for California’s Immigrant Heritage Month to a Forbes article and PBS’ Two Cents series that targets millennials and Gen Z.

100+

datapoints about immigrants and their contributions

America's story is an immigrant story.

logoimg