Defending the Constitutional Right of Longtime Residents to Challenge Their Detention

Sosnava Rodriguez v. Ortega, Case No. 26-50183 (5th Cir. July 2, 2026); Villegas Angel v. Mullin, Case No. 26-50219 (5th Cir. July 2, 2026); Gomez Alvarado v. Vergara, Case No. 26-50221 (5th Cir. July 2, 2026)

Date Filed: April 23, 2026

Status: 

PENDING

On October 23, 2026, the en banc Fifth Circuit rejected the petitioners’ due process challenge to their mandatory detention. For a detailed explanation of the court’s holdings and information about habeas claims for unadmitted noncitizens that may remain viable in the Fifth Circuit, please see the following Practice Alert, Sosnava Rodriguez v. Vergara and 8 U.S.C. § 1225(b)(2)(A) Detention in the Fifth Circuit.

In 2025, the Department of Homeland Security and the Department of Justice abandoned three decades of agency practice and judicial understanding by arguing that the mandatory detention provision at 8 U.S.C. § 1225(b)(2) applies to all noncitizens who entered the United States without inspection. Notably, over 400 federal district court judges from across the country, appointed by every president since Ronald Reagan, and nine federal appeals courts, have rejected the government’s new interpretation of the statute. But in Buenrostro-Mendez v. Bondi, 166 F.4th 494 (5th Cir. 2026) the Fifth Circuit embraced the government’s new reading. Thus all noncitizens who entered without inspection who are detained pending their removal proceedings within the Fifth Circuit—which includes Texas, Louisiana, and Mississippi, and is the circuit with the largest detained population—are no longer eligible as a statutory matter to a bond hearing. The legality of the government’s statutory interpretation will be decided by the Supreme Court in 2027, in Rhoney v. Barbosa da Cunha (No. 26-104).

In the aftermath of the Fifth Circuit’s decision in Buenrostro-Mendez, district courts within the circuit continued to grant habeas petitions on Fifth Amendment due process grounds. The habeas petitioners in this case—Miguel Angel Gomez Alvarado, Ignacio Sosnava Rodriguez, and Alejandro Villegas Angel—have lived in the United States for decades after entering without inspection. None have criminal histories. All three are raising young U.S. citizen children who depend on them in myriad ways. In each case, the district court found that while Buenrostro-Mendez dictated that they were subject to mandatory detention under § 1225(b)(2), their detention without a bond hearing violated due process. The court ordered their immediate release and forbade their re-detention without a bond hearing. The government appealed all three decisions and sought expedited review. The Fifth Circuit heard oral argument in these consolidated appeals on April 29, 2026.

On July 2, 2026, a three-judge panel of the Fifth Circuit initially ruled in favor of the petitioners, affirming —for a time— the district courts’ grants of habeas in each case. The majority of the panel held that noncitizens subject to mandatory detention under 8 U.S.C. § 1225(b)(2) have the right to meaningful due process protections and are thus entitled to bond hearings at which the government justifies their detention within 90 days without filing an individual habeas petition.

However, on Friday, July 10, 2026, the Fifth Circuit decided to rehear the case en banc and vacated the panel’s decision pending rehearing. On July 21, 2026, the Fifth Circuit granted the government’s motion to stay the district court judgments pending en banc review. The full en banc court heard argument on September 24, 2026. On October 23, 2026, in a splintered 10-7 decision with multiple dissents, the en banc Fifth Circuit issued a decision reversing the district court judgments, concluding that noncitizens who entered the country without admission have no constitutional due process right to challenge their detention without a bond hearing. Petitioners’ counsel released a statement condemning the decision, available here.

The petitioners are represented by the American Immigration Council, the National Immigration Project, Garza & Narvaez, PLCC, and Law Offices of Stephen A. Lagana.


Documents & Others


Consolidated Government Opening Brief

March 24, 2026

View File

Petitioners’ Answering Brief

April 23, 2026

View File

Constitutional Accountability Center Amicus Brief

April 24, 2026

View File

Immigrant Legal Services Providers and Faith Groups' Amicus Brief

April 24, 2026

View File

Government Reply Brief

April 27, 2026

View File

Petitioners' 28(j) Letter regarding Barbosa da Cunha v. Freden

April 28, 2026

View File

Petitioners' 28(j) Letter regarding Lopez-Campos v. Raycraft

May 12, 2026

View File

Petitioners' 28(j) Letter regarding Santillan Quiroz v. Mullin

July 1, 2026

View File

Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals’ Decision Affirming Grants of Habeas Corpus

July 2, 2026

View File

Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals’ Order Vacating Panel Decision Pending En Banc Review

July 10, 2026

View File

Government Motion for Precedential Order Staying District Court Orders

July 10, 2026

View File

Government Motion to Expedite Stay Motion

July 13, 2026

View File

Petitioners' Opposition to Motion to Expedite Stay Motion

July 14, 2026

View File

Government Reply in support of Motion to Expedite

July 16, 2026

View File

Petitioners' Opposition to Motion for Precedential Stay Order

July 17, 2026

View File

Fifth Circuit Stay Order

July 21, 2026

View File

Government's Supplemental En Banc Brief

August 10, 2026

View File

Petitioners' Supplemental En Banc Brief

September 9, 2026

View File

Petitioners' 28(j) Letter regarding Lopez Garcia v. Guadian

September 10, 2026

View File

Amicus Brief from Immigrant Legal Services Providers, Immigration Law Professors, and Immigration Clinic Directors

September 11, 2026

View File

Amicus Brief from the Constitutional Accountability Center

September 11, 2026

View File

Amicus Brief from Industry Leaders and Representatives

September 16, 2026

View File

Petitioners' 28(j) Letter regarding Padilla v. U.S. ICE

September 21, 2026

View File

En Banc Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals Decision Reversing the Grants of Habeas Corpus

October 23, 2026

View File

Practice Alert, Sosnava Rodriguez v. Vergara and 8 U.S.C. § 1225(b)(2)(A) Detention in the Fifth Circuit

November 12, 2026

View File
Post

Federal Court Delivers Major Blow to Trump Detention Policy of Jailing Immigrants With No Hearing, No Explanation 

WASHINGTON, D.C., July 3, 2026 — On July 2, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit ruled that people facing immigration detention have the right to meaningful due process protections and must be afforded a bond hearing within 90 days. The decision deals a major blow to… Read More
Read More
Post

Federal Court Hears Case That Could Allow Unchecked Immigration Detention

April 29, 2026 (New Orleans, LA) — On April 29, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit heard oral arguments in a set of cases that could determine whether people can be held in immigration detention without ever getting any chance to challenge why they are being… Read More
Read More

Map The Impact

Explore immigration data where you live

Our Map the Impact tool has comprehensive coverage of more than 100 data points about immigrants and their contributions in all 50 states and the country overall. It continues to be widely cited in places ranging from Gov. Newsom’s declaration for California’s Immigrant Heritage Month to a Forbes article and PBS’ Two Cents series that targets millennials and Gen Z.

100+

datapoints about immigrants and their contributions

Related Resources

America's story is an immigrant story.

logoimg